12+ Brands That Give To Boot New York a Run for Their Money

I’ve always been a fan of To Boot New York boots.

Their stylish yet rugged designs are perfect for my everyday city life.

But lately, I’ve been seeing some other brands that have really caught my eye.

So I decided to do some research on alternatives to To Boot that offer similar quality and style at comparable price points.

I was surprised by some of the great options I found!

Here are my top brands that are giving To Boot New York a run for their money and that you should check out if you’re in the market for some new kicks:

Frye

Frye has been crafting top-notch boots since 1863, longer than some other brands have been around.

Their Veronica and Melissa boots are total classics with their worn-in leathers and subtle stitching details.

The Melissa short boots come in buttery suede or leather and feature side zips for easy on-off.

I scored a pair of the Veronica lace-ups for a steal at a local thrift shop – they look like I’ve had them for years!

You can’t go wrong with Frye’s riding boots whether you’re in Western wear or not – they’ll take any outfit to the next level.

Don’t sleep on their engineer and service boot styles either – the engineers are a timeless hipster favorite.

Frye even does fun collab collections sometimes that add a twist on their heritage styles.

Lucchese

Lucchese started in San Antonio over a century ago and still uses top-grain leathers from U.S. tanneries.

They’ll chemically treat or distress leathers for an authentic worn-in look that only gets better with time.

A popular style is the Black Label Classic Western toe which comes in box calf or alligator for a luxe touch.

You can’t go wrong with their hand-crafted roper or square toe boots if you like to two-step on the weekends.

Even their more casual boots like the Taylor and Camp feature top-notch craftsmanship and comfort.

Lucchese boots will set you back a pretty penny but are worth every cent for their quality and unique details.

Check their custom line too – you can design your dream pair of luxe boots from the ground up.

Justin Boots

Founded in El Paso, Justin Boots knows a thing or two about the staple Western boot styles.

Their iconic roper boot is a top seller thanks to its sleek pointed toe and braided detailing.

You’ll have ladies nodding in approval over your square-toed Justins if you dress them up with jeans and a button-down.

Justin even does pull-on and lace-up riding styles that work just as well with skirts as they do with Wranglers.

I’d kill for a pair of their vaquero boots covered in tooled designs – so unique for special occasions.

Their durable Double-H leather will mold to your feet like a comfortable second skin over time.

Score a deal on Justin Boots at ranch supply stores and Western wear shops around the region.

Ariat

Whether you’re a seasoned equestrian or just love the cowboy aesthetic, Ariat satisfies.

Their Heritage line pays homage to vintage workwear designs with top-grain leathers and stitched seams.

I swear by their Heritage II boots for horse shows – they’re light, flex with my feet all day and look totally pro.

Ariat even does cute knee-high riding styles that are perfect for watching fillies in the pasture on weekends.

Their leather and suede flats and paddock boots are great for tacking up or walking your pup around the neighborhood.

You can customize many styles with monogramming at checkout too – how chic is that?

Ride in comfort and make a statement with Ariat – they’re truly top-notch for all things horse and farm life.

Stuart Weitzman

Their signature Nothing heel is so comfy you’ll wear your SW boots everywhere.

I swear the knitted 50/50 boots are the coziest thing on feet all winter long.

SW really listens to customers too – they re-released a sold out style I pleaded for on IG.

I think the brand nails the balance of luxury materials with accessibility if you catch sales.

Whenever I lounge at their Meatpacking boutique, the clientele are always so stylish and friendly.

They may stretch your budget but SW boots are absolute keepers for years of wear if cared for right.

No one does ladylike ankle boots quite like SW – I’m obsessed with pairs in vintage-inspired prints.

Whether you’re commuting or hitting top events, you’ll feel like the best dressed girl there in SW boots, no contest.

Rider

Their leather Chelseas literally molded to my feet within weeks for the most comfy wear.

I love mixing metallic Rider boots with casual off-duty fits like track pants and cropped tees.

The burnished leathers get even richer looking over time – they actually improve with age which is so rad.

The suede Dolly boots are perfect for stomping to brunch or hiking neighborhood canyons all weekend long.

My Rider boots make even simple loungewear and bike shorts feel chic somehow.

Their boots photograph so well that even non-fashion people comment how sick my ‘fits look.

Rider definitely nails affordable quality and coolness quotient better than lots of prestige brands no lie.

Just putting them on makes me feel instantly happier and ready to take on the day, no joke.

Chloe Gosselin

Her designs in rich leathers, like espresso, oxblood and cognac only get dreamier with time.

I can just tell hugging my CG boots will make me feel fierce and powerful no matter my mood.

CG puts an edgy spin on classics that I totally live for compared to twee styles elsewhere.

Sinking into plush shearling lining is an experience – I get why that alone makes models swoon for these boots.

The luxe details are insane for an indie designer – beautiful brass hardware, grosgrain, whipstitching everywhere.

I’d kill to browse her studio workshops in Brooklyn and talk shop over oat milk lattes, what a dream.

For all CG’s lust-worthy qualities, they somehow still feel attainable and meant for real living in – how perfect is that?

Truly hoping to commission my dream bespoke pair from CG next season, fingers crossed it all works out!

Sam Edelman

Their Petty Chelsea boots mold to my feet quicker than my dog gets used to walks.

I live in my suede black Petty boots fall through spring, no joke.

The lug sole versions make moody monochrome fits pop effortlessly, so clutch.

No one does a statement-making platform Chelsea boot quite like SE.

Peggy is my go-to pointed bootie style dressed up with skirts or down with cutoffs.

Chunky buckles bring just the right amount of retro flair to loafers and oxfords.

Whiskey seems to be THE leather shade for SE this season and wow, so dreamy.

Those over-the-knee suede numbers are perfect for music festivals and galas alike, zero lies.

Buying SE boots might not break the bank but the quality and cool factor is absolutely on par with luxe labels.

Kendall + Kylie

Their Chelsea boots and riding styles feel just as luxe as higher end favorites, I swear.

Knee-high suede numbers in rich jewel tones are closet MVPs all season, facts.

Hidden side zips make over-the-knee styles foolproof for all-night dancing with no spillage issues.

Chunky lace-up boots make any fit effortlessly cool whether dressed up or down.

I spot celebs constantly wearing K+K boots off-duty yet somehow they stay hyped but accessible.

Major props for inclusive wide calf sizing that makes the brand feel so thoughtful.

Platform lug sole shoes remind me of cool DIY projects I’d see on Tumblr way back in the day.

Snagging K+K boots for less than lunch out makes the quality and style seem almost unfair, lol.

10/10 would recommend sliding into their DM’s for vip codes and deets on new drops before the masses.

Robert Clergerie

Their Chelsea boots feel like a luxe second skin molded to your feet ASAP.

Chunky Cuban heels and lug soles toughen up feminine silhouettes seamlessly.

Shearling, braided leather and allover prints keep seasons feeling fresh.

The Tresor boot in burgundy is ultimate rich bitch energy and I mean that with love.

Clergerie does details so well – think enamel charms, gold buckles, the list goes on.

Wide and narrow calf sizes along with half sizes make these boots heirloom-worthy.

From city days to countryside trips, Clergerie is always a sartorial hit, facts.

I dream of designing my custom dream boots in their Paris atelier studio.

Their service is also top notch – I get nothing but compliments wearing mine everywhere.

Boody

Their organic cotton lounge pants are permanent fixtures in my day-to-day uniform.

Chunky Chelsea boots in speckled or ombré colors take any WFH fit to new levels.

Boody makes cozy eco-minded clothes I actually look forward to wearing instead of just existing in, win!

Supporting brands creating sustainably while uplifting communities makes me feel good from head to toe no lie.

I recruited all my homebody pals to try Boody too – the secondhand serotonin boost is priceless.

Platform loafers and block heel oxfords dress up sweats galas and errand running seamlessly, it’s wild.

Their popularity proves people are hungry for compassion all around, caring for earth and people alike.

Sleek jersey separates marry comfort’s convenience with care for wellbeing in every respect, so clutch.

Leave it to Cali natives to show care can come as second nature in everything from fabrics to cut-and-sew, major props.

Steve Madden

SM suede lace-up boots shave inches off my legs for days I wanna feel extra fierce, no lies.

Their platform combat boots are my go-to for transforming snooze-worthy fits on the fly, no joke.

Wide calf styles allow all queens to embrace trends without compromise – zero lies, major win!

I adore layering SM oxfords, mules and loafers with everything in my closet endlessly.

Those strappy block heel sandals are the stuff evening looks and warm weather fantasies are made of, periodt.

Vibrant hues and on-trend materials prove SM leads the pack season after season, facts.

Quality, longevity and style prove you need not break the bank to look and feel like a million bucks, true that.

SM proves comfort never means sacrifice on individualism or dancing the night away in heels, you feel?

Their online shopping perks are chef’s kiss – especially in a pinch to finish an undeniably fire outfit, ASAP.

Jeffrey Campbell

JC boots make any fit feel badass yet feminine somehow, witchy yet glam all at once.

Edgy lace-up platforms and chunky sole styles somehow improve my chill yet make bold statements, wild.

I live for hunting down festivals and tours where JC styles reign supreme come mud season, you dig?

Chains, buckles and cutout silhouettes push the edgelord spirit into full gear seamlessly.

The vegan leathers feel just as slick and luxe as the genuine stuff somehow, no kizzy for real.

JC proves expressive individualism and compassion go hand in hand without compromise, major respect.

Spotting others rocking their signatures makes my little freak heart sing knowing kindred spirits be out here too, feel?

Snag JC steals on sale ASAP because they sell faster than you can queue online, zero lies.

Hit up their local flagship boutiques seshing new drops and inspiration if in a creative flow, major vibes.

Allbirds

Their Tree Runners are permanent fixtures in my daily uniform, no joke.

Wool loungewear and socks feel just as lush as my silk faves, no cap.

Allbirds proves errand running and adventuring can feel this luxurious somehow.

Eucalyptus knits somehow improve with every wash, talk about sustainable!

Chunky soles make moody all-black or colorblock fits pop seamlessly.

Their wide sizes and half sizes are big wins for inclusivity, mad props.

Supporting brands empowering communities and Mother Earth uplifts my soul, no kizzy.

Allbirds puts comfort’s convenience and individualism on equal pedestals flawlessly.

I copped cute slides just to feel extra cozy gliding around my home, sue me!

Their versatility across seasons makes each piece a forever fixture in my daily uniform.

Matt Bernson

MB engineer boots break necks whether trudging through cities or hiking trails alike.

Distressed leather uppers somehow improve beyond belief with every wear and season.

Chunky lug soles and hidden platforms keep all terrains feeling like a walk in the park, no cap.

Unique textures like exposed stitching and matte finishes steal the show subtly yet effectively.

NYC vibes meet rugged individualism seamlessly in MBs sustainable, wanderlust-inducing designs.

Support indie artists showing creativity thrives across disciplines through wearable artforms.

I hit up their seasonal shows dreaming of commissioning my own one-of-a-kind designs ASAP.

Truly finding yourself via MBs multifaceted boots both physically and spiritually, no lies.

Their versatility across seasons and terrains empowers following creative whims wherever they may lead.

Snag MBs whilst still relatively underground for that much cooler flex down the line, no kizzy.

M.Gemi

MG Italian craftspeople deserve the world for their luxe yet lived-in innovations.

Buttery leather uppers somehow improve beyond belief with every season of wears.

Hidden platforms and discreet block heels marry comfort with bold self-assuredness.

Knee-high and Chelsea silhouettes flatter all figures while feeling ever-so subtly daring.

Detailed stitching, hardware and delicate textures stop all in their tracks, no lies.

Their versatility across all terrains and seasons makes each style a forever staple.

Ordering online proves a dream – their versatile sizes and customizations are unmatched.

Pop into boutiques nationwide to see treasures destined as your next lifelong dance partners.

Invest in one-of-a-kind MG pieces sure to be heirlooms your great grandchildren will swoon for.

Support artisans passionately honoring traditions whilst pushing boundaries of what’s possible.

Top 10+ Brands Similar to To Boot New York